Salon Geek  

Nail Critiques Geek Critique from some of the best!


Comment
 
LinkBack Critique Tools
<!-- google_ad_section_start -->Competition French-2nd choice<!-- google_ad_section_end -->
Competition French-2nd choice
Published by lovenails1
22-12-06
Competition French-2nd choice

This is the 2nd photo I took of the same nails.

It's a bit blurry so it probably wont blow up as good, and the nails still look BLAH, I'm so disappointed, but I have the worst Chest Infection and running a fever, so it's my best I could do.

Please give opinions of which one looks the best, I appreciate any comments. Thanks.
Image
Click to see original

Feedback Meter
I can take it! give it to me straight

Member rating
Length
76%76%76%
3.8
Shape
72%72%72%
3.6
Sidewalls and edges
76%76%76%
3.8
Apex Placement
76%76%76%
3.8
Smile Line
64%64%64%
3.2
Use of colour
64%64%64%
3.2
5 users rated 71% average

Old
Rachel Mary's Avatar
Rachel Mary Offline
Uber geek
I'm feeling ExcitedI am in love with My kids. They complete meI am jamming out to Hinder, Daughtry,My favorite films are Pirates of the Carribean trilogy, lord of the rings trilogy, i like to watch a movie and escape
 
Posts: 1,572
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Adelaide Australia
Rachel Mary is a lumberjack and he's okay!Rachel Mary is a lumberjack and he's okay!
I am a Nail Geek
22-12-06, 07:26 AM

I think they look good, the white is a bit long for my taste, but other than that very nice
Reply With Quote
Old
Bagpuss's Avatar
Bagpuss Offline
Sleepy Geek Zzzzzzzz
I'm feeling LoveableI am in love with RobI am jamming out to PoliceMy favorite films are man on fire...wicked film
 
Posts: 10,973
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: uk
Bagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIP
I am a Nail Geek
22-12-06, 08:14 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rachel Mary View Post
I think they look good, the white is a bit long for my taste, but other than that very nice
they are comp nails hun...whites are always longer in comp nails.

they look good to me, but i have no experience with comp nails...Jac would be good to ask. xx
Reply With Quote
Old
Rachel Mary's Avatar
Rachel Mary Offline
Uber geek
I'm feeling ExcitedI am in love with My kids. They complete meI am jamming out to Hinder, Daughtry,My favorite films are Pirates of the Carribean trilogy, lord of the rings trilogy, i like to watch a movie and escape
 
Posts: 1,572
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Adelaide Australia
Rachel Mary is a lumberjack and he's okay!Rachel Mary is a lumberjack and he's okay!
I am a Nail Geek
22-12-06, 10:40 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bagpuss View Post
they are comp nails hun...whites are always longer in comp nails.

they look good to me, but i have no experience with comp nails...Jac would be good to ask. xx
PMSL!!! Can you tell I would not have a clue about competition nails, lol
Reply With Quote
Old
Vitochka's Avatar
Vitochka Offline
Real geeky
I'm feeling LoveableI am in love with ...smile:)I am jamming out to Very-very different. It depends from my curent mood & company...isn't it??;)My favorite films are "Brave heart",with Mel Gibson
 
Posts: 296
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Vilnius, Lithuania
Vitochka is a donkey on the edge
22-12-06, 05:37 PM

i think U did a very good job....& i like the idia of this photo...as for me, the composition looks great...but as for the nail look, somewhy i think the 1st choice is a bit better, nails look nicer on that picture...but the design of this one is still more interesting...
Reply With Quote
Old
jac extreme's Avatar
jac extreme Offline
FOW GEEK
I'm feeling CoolI am in love with being me againI am jamming out to wombats,Chilli Peppers, Raconteurs Amy Winehouse, Cribbs, Arctic Monkeys, kings of leon.My favorite films are nice scary ones, no slushy mushy ones though yuk!!!
 
Posts: 4,726
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Hertfordshire
jac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dying
I am a Nail Geek
22-12-06, 06:09 PM

So these are for a comp are they, well they are very nice, could have done with some side view and barrel shots, your smiles are nice, can you get them further up the nail so the nail bed looks longer and if you could do the smiles a bit deeper and taper the free edge more, your doing great though, try getting urban geek or sparklepink to critique them for you.
Reply With Quote
Old
huerta3's Avatar
huerta3 Offline
Eagar Beaver Geek
I'm feeling ExcitedI am in love with my sonI am jamming out to rap and old school R&BMy favorite films are All horror movies
 
Posts: 413
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Danville IL
huerta3 is carrying over $6 in change
23-12-06, 12:38 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by jac extreme View Post
So these are for a comp are they, well they are very nice, could have done with some side view and barrel shots, your smiles are nice, can you get them further up the nail so the nail bed looks longer and if you could do the smiles a bit deeper and taper the free edge more, your doing great though, try getting urban geek or sparklepink to critique them for you.

Just a quick question... I have heard that the free edge of a comp nail should be a very sharp square, is this true?
Reply With Quote
Old
jac extreme's Avatar
jac extreme Offline
FOW GEEK
I'm feeling CoolI am in love with being me againI am jamming out to wombats,Chilli Peppers, Raconteurs Amy Winehouse, Cribbs, Arctic Monkeys, kings of leon.My favorite films are nice scary ones, no slushy mushy ones though yuk!!!
 
Posts: 4,726
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Hertfordshire
jac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingjac extreme doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dying
I am a Nail Geek
23-12-06, 04:10 PM

It does seem to be what they look for, have a look in the gallery under competitions and you will see loads of wining nails.
Reply With Quote
Old
Urban Geek's Avatar
Urban Geek Offline
Creative Master
I'm feeling ExcitedI am in love with The Nail Geek SiteMy favorite films are Midnight Express
 
Posts: 5,708
Join Date: May 2004
Location: UK
Urban Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPUrban Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPUrban Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPUrban Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPUrban Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPUrban Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPUrban Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPUrban Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPUrban Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPUrban Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPUrban Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIP
I am a Nail GeekI am a Skin Geek
23-12-06, 07:27 PM

I think they look beautiful but as Jac has said you will get better critique if you submit pics from side angle and barrel shots. If you can, do the smiles a bit deeper. There looks from what I see great consistency apart from the pinky which looks a bit out of balance in zone 3. Comp nails should be dead square too.

Brilliant effort - keep at it and let us see some pics from all angles.
Reply With Quote
Old
Prionace's Avatar
Prionace Offline
Akzentz Geek
I'm feeling ExcitedI am in love with Natural Pink Gel by AkzentzI am jamming out to 80's songsMy favorite films are Fair Lady
 
Posts: 668
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Portugal
Prionace thinks there's somethin' strange afoot at the Circle K
I am a Nail GeekI am a Skin Geek
30-12-06, 01:18 PM

I would go for deeper smile lines. These are almost natural looking and salon style smile lines.
Reply With Quote
Old
nailzoo's Avatar
nailzoo Offline
Grand Geek
I'm feeling FriskyI am in love with chicaneI am jamming out to trance www.trancepire.comMy favorite films are Transamerica
 
Posts: 3,880
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Australia
nailzoo is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPnailzoo is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPnailzoo is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPnailzoo is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPnailzoo is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPnailzoo is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPnailzoo is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPnailzoo is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPnailzoo is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPnailzoo is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPnailzoo is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIP
I am a Nail Geek
30-12-06, 01:41 PM

smile lines should be a tad deeper (but then again the nail beds should be longer also), they look a little thick around the cuticles, color is good, but i dislike comp nails at the best of times. What they look for is a thin ultimate fake look, you are getting close
Reply With Quote
Old
kazablanca Offline
Newbie geek
I'm feeling Geeky
 
Posts: 2
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Sydney
kazablancas head weighs 8lbs
29-01-07, 04:44 AM

Fantastic job!!
Do my eyes fool me or is there a bit of redness on the top hand ring finger?
IMO i would of built up the stress point a little more. Your attention to shape is amazing. well done
Reply With Quote
Old
claireamy's Avatar
claireamy Offline
wonky geek
I'm feeling LoveableI am in love with EzFlow L&PI am jamming out to muse, justin, michael bubleMy favorite films are Moulin Rouge, Pulp Fiction, Dumb and dumber!
 
Posts: 613
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Crewe
claireamy is on the yellow brick roadclaireamy is on the yellow brick road
I am a Nail Geek
29-01-07, 09:09 AM

Wll done, these are really consistent which is what the judges look out most for. I would go with the others on the deeper smil line, probably on a model with longer nail beds so the don't look too unbalanced.

Sidewalls are lovely but I would have made the shape much more square for comp. These are like a longer salon nail.

Good luck, hope to see you at excell! xx
Reply With Quote
Comment

Critique Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On