My critique example (READ FIRST) - Salon Geek
Salon Geek  

Nail Critiques Geek Critique from some of the best!


Comment
 
LinkBack Critique Tools
<!-- google_ad_section_start -->My critique example (READ FIRST)<!-- google_ad_section_end -->
My critique example (READ FIRST)
Published by The Geek
05-12-06
My critique example (READ FIRST)

Here is an example of how to submit a critique and also how to rate one.

Submitting a critique
  1. Click the new Critique button (you must be registered and logged in to submit a critique).
  2. Enter a title for the critique (i.e. My cute nail).
  3. Click the browse button to navigate to a jpeg image on your computer. This will upload the image for you. You do not have to be a premium geek to do this - however if you want to add additional pictures (i.e. different angles) then you will need to upload the additional images with the attachment system which is only availible for premium geeks.
  4. Select the strength of the feedback meter (strong, medium or wooseyish).
  5. Tick the relevant areas you want critiquing on. For instance, its daft to have your smile line critiqued if its a single colour application. Likewise its daft to have Use of colour or design ticked if there is no freaking design on it.
PLEASE NOTE: You will NOT be able to change your critique areas once you submit the thread so choose wisely!

How to rate:

You can rate when you reply to the author OR you can select the Rate Now option next to the rating while viewing the critique. Please note that you should respect the authors feedback meter. Abuse of the ratings can lead to infractions, mega bad reputation and/or banning from the site (yes, the mods can view your ratings).

Please don't respond with a lame 'thats nice'. See if you can string more than 2 words together like 'Thats a great use of colour there bobby' (see, thats 8 words!). Even better would be something constructive.

Please note that the people who submit the critique can delete the critique whenever they want.

nJoy

Edit: If you guys tick areas for critique that are not relevant (i.e. smile lines when you CANT even see them) your overall rating will be affected greatly (in a downward kind of way!!!).
Image
Click to see original

Feedback Meter
I can take it! give it to me straight

Member rating
Length
86.2%86.2%86.2%
4.31
Shape
88.4%88.4%88.4%
4.42
Sidewalls and edges
87%87%87%
4.35
Apex Placement
85.4%85.4%85.4%
4.27
Smile Line
83.8%83.8%83.8%
4.19
26 users rated 86% average

Old
Lellipop's Avatar
Lellipop Offline
Lelli Loo Loo
Lellipop is down but not out
I'm feeling LoveableI am in love with LifeI am jamming out to Dont stop me now - Queen I love it.My favorite films are Green mile
 
Posts: 9,798
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Lellipop Land
Lellipop is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPLellipop is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPLellipop is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPLellipop is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPLellipop is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPLellipop is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPLellipop is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPLellipop is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPLellipop is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPLellipop is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPLellipop is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIP
I am a Nail Geek
05-12-06, 03:24 PM

You have done a good job Samuel lol However there does seem to be a slight gap between the smile line and the pink try to butt your white a little nearer to your pink
Reply With Quote
Old
Bagpuss's Avatar
Bagpuss Offline
Sleepy Geek Zzzzzzzz
Bagpuss is in love
I'm feeling LoveableI am in love with RobI am jamming out to PoliceMy favorite films are man on fire...wicked film
 
Posts: 11,514
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: uk
Bagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPBagpuss is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIP
I am a Nail Geek
05-12-06, 03:43 PM

its very short and flat, it just looks like a mans nail....ooopppps sorry i was looking at the wrong nail....
Reply With Quote
Old
Little Angel's Avatar
Little Angel Offline
Grand Geek
Little Angel is in lala land
I'm feeling SassyI am in love with solar oil
 
Posts: 3,073
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Lincolnshire, England
Little Angel wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSLittle Angel wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSLittle Angel wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSLittle Angel wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSLittle Angel wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSLittle Angel wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARS
I am a Hair GeekI am a Nail GeekI am a Skin Geek
05-12-06, 03:49 PM

Thats not too bad an attempt for a beginner sam, try harder next time, 1 house point



ps 1 being the lowest score and 5 the highest??
Reply With Quote
Old
The Geek's Avatar
The Geek Offline
Grand Master Geek
The Geek is on fire!!!!
I'm feeling SassyI am in love with Mrs GeekI am jamming out to Beck, New Order, CrackerMy favorite films are Bad B Rate Horror Films.
 
Posts: 4,681
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Leeds, UK
The Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPThe Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPThe Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPThe Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPThe Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPThe Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPThe Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPThe Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPThe Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPThe Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIPThe Geek is King of the Swingers, the jungle VIP
I am a Hair GeekI am a Nail Geek
05-12-06, 03:52 PM

Gee. Thanks all

Yes, 1 is the lowest, 5 is the highest (except in the overall category). I think I am finished now with the tweaks
Reply With Quote
Old
phoebe_cat's Avatar
phoebe_cat Offline
Doing off to N.Cyprus!!
phoebe_cat is Cold!
I'm feeling ExcitedI am in love with SteveI am jamming out to Ska, punk, reggae & cheese!!!My favorite films are Goodfellas, Brat Pack & Grease
 
Posts: 607
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: South Shields (GeordieLand)
phoebe_cat has a pencil up their nose and says Wibble!phoebe_cat has a pencil up their nose and says Wibble!phoebe_cat has a pencil up their nose and says Wibble!phoebe_cat has a pencil up their nose and says Wibble!phoebe_cat has a pencil up their nose and says Wibble!
I am a Nail Geek
05-12-06, 03:59 PM

Well done Sam!! With a little bit of work, you could maybe make a career out of this nail malarky!

After the heated debate on Saturday this should keep everyone happy Can't wait to play!

Last edited by phoebe_cat; 05-12-06 at 03:59 PM.. Reason: spelling!
Reply With Quote
Old
mynails13's Avatar
mynails13 Offline
Real geeky
mynails13 is in lala land
I'm feeling GeekyI am in love with Austin-my doggyI am jamming out to anything EXCEPT Country-Western!!My favorite films are Comedies, Comic Books-turned into movies and chick flicks
 
Posts: 308
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Manchester, NH USA
mynails13 is carrying over $6 in change
05-12-06, 05:21 PM

You are the best! This will totally make everyone happy!
Reply With Quote
Old
aliceellen1974's Avatar
aliceellen1974 Offline
Very geeky
aliceellen1974 is in lala land
I'm feeling WhateverI am jamming out to linkin park,madonna, robbie (of course!!)My favorite films are terminator 2, Billy Elliott
 
Posts: 588
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: west midlands
aliceellen1974 is a donkey on the edge
05-12-06, 08:27 PM

excellent idea........ great that we get listened to on here.........

samuel you go away for the weekent and all hell broke loose on here LOL LOL don't do it again!!!

must be the stress of christmas

xxxxxxxxxxx
Reply With Quote
Old
HeatherDavis's Avatar
HeatherDavis Offline
geekstess w/the mostest
HeatherDavis is EXCITED! Can't believe I won!!!
I'm feeling SmartI am in love with DIOR SHOW MASCARA, and my Ultra Sculptor#10I am jamming out to anything that's got a good beat you can dance to, and isn't POLKAMy favorite films are Phantom of the Opera, Rocky Horror Picture Show, Wizard of Oz, Sixteen Candles, Boondock Saints
 
Posts: 1,398
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Grand Junction, CO, USA
HeatherDavis is showing me the money!HeatherDavis is showing me the money!HeatherDavis is showing me the money!HeatherDavis is showing me the money!HeatherDavis is showing me the money!HeatherDavis is showing me the money!HeatherDavis is showing me the money!HeatherDavis is showing me the money!
I am a Nail Geek
05-12-06, 08:32 PM

I LOVE THIS!! But now I feel all competitive and want to do nails and post pictures and see what is SAID. Like my run-on sentence?

GREAT GREAT GREAT IDEA!!
Reply With Quote
Old
nailartist's Avatar
nailartist Offline
sparkly pink princess
nailartist is in lala land
I'm feeling FriskyI am in love with Clients! :)I am jamming out to New FlamencoMy favorite films are Classic Star Wars, Anne of Green Gables, Contact, The Matrix
 
Posts: 406
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Washington state, US
nailartist is a lumberjack and he's okay!nailartist is a lumberjack and he's okay!
I am a Nail Geek
05-12-06, 08:35 PM

Great job, Samuel. I'm with Heather--I'm feeling a bit competitive too!
Reply With Quote
Old
Keri2000 Offline
Geeklette
Keri2000 is in lala land
I'm feeling Geeky
 
Posts: 28
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Colorado Springs, CO USA
Keri2000s head weighs 8lbs
I am a Nail Geek
05-12-06, 08:48 PM

What an EXCELLENT solution. This is really awesome! Sam, thanks so much for taking time out of your day to do something like this for us.
Reply With Quote
Old
Katelisa's Avatar
Katelisa Offline
Grand Geek
Katelisa is a genuis
I'm feeling FriskyI am in love with Laptop!!!I am jamming out to anything and everything!!My favorite films are forgetting sarah marshall, and wild child, so what is its for 15 year old girls... its amazing!!
 
Posts: 2,626
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Brummy Land
Katelisa has got a hickie from KenickieKatelisa has got a hickie from KenickieKatelisa has got a hickie from KenickieKatelisa has got a hickie from KenickieKatelisa has got a hickie from KenickieKatelisa has got a hickie from KenickieKatelisa has got a hickie from KenickieKatelisa has got a hickie from KenickieKatelisa has got a hickie from KenickieKatelisa has got a hickie from Kenickie
I am a Nail GeekI am a Skin Geek
05-12-06, 09:08 PM

what a bloody marvelous idea!!!

good one genius!

x
Reply With Quote
Old
VHunter's Avatar
VHunter Offline
Grand Geek
VHunter is going absolutely mad
I'm feeling FriskyI am jamming out to Shania TwainMy favorite films are Million Dollar Baby
 
Posts: 5,879
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Montreal QC, Canada
VHunter doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingVHunter doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingVHunter doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingVHunter doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingVHunter doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingVHunter doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingVHunter doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingVHunter doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingVHunter doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingVHunter doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dyingVHunter doesn't want to achieve immortality through their work. They want to achieve it through not dying
I am a Hair GeekI am a Nail Geek
05-12-06, 10:45 PM

AWESOME work Sam!!

Loving this critique thing!!
This way, we can make sure all our questions are answered regarding the work we've posted.
FANTASTIC JOB AND EVEN MORE FANTASTIC IDEA!!


(<---- that's a pat on the back, not a grope by the way )
Reply With Quote
Old
Spice's Avatar
Spice Offline
Newbie geek
Spice is in lala land
I'm feeling Geeky
 
Posts: 2
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: CANADA
Spices head weighs 8lbs
Thumbs up Fantastic!!!!!!!!!!!!!! - 06-12-06, 12:12 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Keri2000 View Post
What an EXCELLENT solution. This is really awesome! Sam, thanks so much for taking time out of your day to do something like this for us.

Love it !!!!!!!!!!!!! incredible ~!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote