Salon Geek
                 

The Nail Geek Nail professionals discussing all aspects of hand and foot care.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
  (#1) Old
Geeky
rayas head weighs 8lbs
Posts: 181
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Essex
Is Shellac the same as Gelish - 11-09-10, 08:00 AM

Trying to get back into offering Gels and was going to purchase the Gelish range but is Shellac the same? xx
Reply With Quote
  (#2) Old
Geeklin
 
Rebecca J's Avatar
Rebecca J is a donkey on the edge
Posts: 45
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Rotherham
11-09-10, 08:07 AM

you would be best to do a search on both as there has been quite a few discussions on both. You may also be as well joining groups for both of them.

It took me 2 weeks to decide which system to choose after all the reading
Reply With Quote
  (#3) Old
Geeky
 
Bezza's Avatar
Bezza thinks there's somethin' strange afoot at the Circle K
Posts: 180
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Leicestershire
11-09-10, 08:39 AM

As rebecca says. There are many many discussions covering this very question.... if you put shellac and gellish into the same search box then you'll find them all quite easily
Reply With Quote
  (#4) Old
Grand Geek
 
mizzy_dizzy's Avatar
mizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocket
Posts: 3,709
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Wichita Kansas !
11-09-10, 09:29 AM

No there not the same,
shellac (as far as I know) is the only hybird polish .

It is made up of acetone soluble polymers , light initiators & the solvents of a polish,
it's also 3 free and it's hypoallergenic ,
it's avalible in 12 of the most classic colors and you can layer it for lots more



best of all there is no buffing to apply or remove
it's a color and not am enhancement .

As far as I know gelish is a very thin soak off
gel ,That comes in indervidial bottles with burshes like a polish or shellac, that currently has more colors than shellac . And can be cured with a LED light .
I don't know it's scince if it's 3free ect I did look on the site it didn't really say anything ,

There are lots of others to now but these seem to be the main 2.
Reply With Quote
  (#5) Old
Grand Geek
 
shedunlop's Avatar
shedunlop says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketshedunlop says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketshedunlop says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketshedunlop says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketshedunlop says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketshedunlop says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketshedunlop says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketshedunlop says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketshedunlop says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketshedunlop says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketshedunlop says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocket
Posts: 3,837
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: www.moonstruckbeautytraining.com
11-09-10, 12:14 PM

I would suggest that you join both Shellac lovers and Gelish lovers groups and get asking lots of questions on there, read through all the posts on them and then make a decision based on what you have read! The science is different but for the client the results are the same, a polish that lasts for at least 3 weeks, soaks off in 10 minutes max and looks as bright and shiney as the day it was put on, no wearing or chipping or peeling. Shellac has 12 colours, more due in March 2011, Gelish has 48 colours at least 24 due by the end of this year.
Reply With Quote
  (#6) Old
Freaky geeky
 
NoLimitNails's Avatar
NoLimitNails is great quiddich championNoLimitNails is great quiddich championNoLimitNails is great quiddich championNoLimitNails is great quiddich championNoLimitNails is great quiddich championNoLimitNails is great quiddich championNoLimitNails is great quiddich championNoLimitNails is great quiddich championNoLimitNails is great quiddich champion
Posts: 1,034
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Denmark
11-09-10, 12:48 PM

As far as 3 free goes Gelish is 3free (I belive Georgie mentioned on another thread) but Shellac is hypoallergenic too. I use both...
Reply With Quote
  (#7) Old
Uber geek
 
katiebbaby's Avatar
katiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARS
Posts: 1,372
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: liverpool uk
12-09-10, 12:48 AM

Hi raya just to agree with above but also add, shellac and gellish are not GELS as such, so they are not for enhancments but for natural nails.

Just with you saying you wanted to start offering gels AGAIN,,, shellac is not a gel it's a hybrid,,there is a huge difference. xx
Reply With Quote
  (#8) Old
Grand Geek
 
mizzy_dizzy's Avatar
mizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocket
Posts: 3,709
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Wichita Kansas !
12-09-10, 12:58 AM

Just to confuse things though lol gelish is a soft gel, and from what I hear there is a builder gelish now
Reply With Quote
  (#9) Old
Uber geek
 
katiebbaby's Avatar
katiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARS
Posts: 1,372
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: liverpool uk
12-09-10, 01:16 AM

ha ha lol just to confuse even more shellac is NOT a gel.,,,,,lol
Reply With Quote
  (#10) Old
Grand Geek
 
mizzy_dizzy's Avatar
mizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocket
Posts: 3,709
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Wichita Kansas !
12-09-10, 01:26 AM

I know
Reply With Quote
  (#11) Old
Uber geek
 
katiebbaby's Avatar
katiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARS
Posts: 1,372
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: liverpool uk
12-09-10, 01:33 AM

I think we should have a blindfold test on two geeks. Using shellac and gelish, does gelish do a close colour? or likewise?

Would be good to see, only I am a CND gal and I love the brand 100% and will honestly say hand on heart would never use any other brand even if I did find it better (never thogh) only as I am brand faithfull iygwim.

However I have heared good things about gelish and seems very good even though shellac and gelish are diffrent in their chemistry, would be good to do a blindfoldtest,and post pics, and guinea pigs could post and comment .

However in hindsight If was me I have all 12 shellac colours and would spot one a mile off,,so would have to do a jo public,,mmmmm good though thogh. xxx
Reply With Quote
  (#12) Old
Grand Geek
 
mizzy_dizzy's Avatar
mizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketmizzy_dizzy says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocket
Posts: 3,709
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Wichita Kansas !
12-09-10, 01:44 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by katiebbaby View Post
I think we should have a blindfold test on two geeks. Using shellac and gelish, does gelish do a close colour? or likewise?

Would be good to see, only I am a CND gal and I love the brand 100% and will honestly say hand on heart would never use any other brand even if I did find it better (never thogh) only as I am brand faithfull iygwim.

xxx
sometimes you have to try other things that are avalible , then you know your compation
I think Geeg was saying she tryed gelish ( or one of the others) I was going to see if I could get a sample nail done at olympia so I could compaire but I'm not going now lol if you are you shuld,
Reply With Quote
  (#13) Old
Uber geek
 
katiebbaby's Avatar
katiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARSkatiebbaby wants to hold the world to ransom for.... 1 MEEELLION DOLLARS
Posts: 1,372
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: liverpool uk
12-09-10, 01:55 AM

ohh I've tried it, but wouldnt use it on clients, dont get me wrong nothing to do with product just I prefer shellac, I love shellac for the fact it is like a polish however gelish is more a gel,,iygwim,,howerver shellac acts like a gel so its fab.

ohhhhh think this has been gone over and over lol
Reply With Quote
  (#14) Old
Grand Geek
 
nailzoo's Avatar
nailzoo says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketnailzoo says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketnailzoo says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketnailzoo says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketnailzoo says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketnailzoo says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketnailzoo says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketnailzoo says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketnailzoo says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketnailzoo says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketnailzoo says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocket
Posts: 5,102
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Australia
13-09-10, 02:13 PM

I think both of them are outrageously expensive and look like a price grab by both companies, I only hope there will be an alternative that wont strip me of so much money to get started.
I already know of some salons selling Bio Sculpt as Shellac
Reply With Quote
  (#15) Old
Master Geek
 
Pooh8bear's Avatar
Pooh8bear says I'll be takin' these urr Huggies - and whatever you got in the till'Pooh8bear says I'll be takin' these urr Huggies - and whatever you got in the till'Pooh8bear says I'll be takin' these urr Huggies - and whatever you got in the till'Pooh8bear says I'll be takin' these urr Huggies - and whatever you got in the till'Pooh8bear says I'll be takin' these urr Huggies - and whatever you got in the till'
Posts: 2,189
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Surrey/Hampshire border England
13-09-10, 03:39 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by nailzoo View Post
I think both of them are outrageously expensive and look like a price grab by both companies, I only hope there will be an alternative that wont strip me of so much money to get started.
I already know of some salons selling Bio Sculpt as Shellac
That's strange because Bio Sculpture is even more expensive per ml than both Shellac & Gelish PUT TOGETHER!!! (I know I have worked it out already as I use Bio Sculpture) & I still want to offer all 3 systems

Also it doesn't seem expensive when you think Chanel sell nail polish for about 14 & they are all top end products.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On





© 1997-2014 Sweet Squared LLP