Salon Geek
                 

The Nail Geek Nail professionals discussing all aspects of hand and foot care.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
  (#1) Old
Geeklin
lovelynailss head weighs 8lbs
Posts: 67
Join Date: May 2010
Location: essex
Rolleyes gelish base n top coat the same ? - 06-07-11, 09:37 PM

hi someone pointed out to me that both the gelish base and their top coat have the exactly the same ingredients in which i checked on my bottles and it is the same in each bottle so this must mean its the same stuff but charge 29.99 for base n 16.99 for top coat but both the same product right ???????????? xx
Reply With Quote
  (#2) Old
Grand Geek
gillian w says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketgillian w says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketgillian w says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketgillian w says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketgillian w says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketgillian w says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketgillian w says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketgillian w says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketgillian w says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketgillian w says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketgillian w says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocket
Posts: 6,033
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: herts
06-07-11, 09:42 PM

Well try using the cheaper one on top/bottom on yourself and see if it works the same.

Last edited by gillian w; 06-07-11 at 09:57 PM.
Reply With Quote
  (#3) Old
Very geeky
 
B-Beauty's Avatar
B-Beauty is a donkey on the edge
Posts: 442
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Dundee
06-07-11, 09:45 PM

I doubt it is the same hun , it could be diff amounts of the same ingredients I personally think base is thicker hth x
Reply With Quote
  (#4) Old
Geeklin
lovelynailss head weighs 8lbs
Posts: 67
Join Date: May 2010
Location: essex
06-07-11, 09:56 PM

as listed its in same order which means the more of ingredients thats in it goes first to the least n both bottles read the same think i will try on myself as sugguested as surely they cant sell the same thing as 2 different products xx
Reply With Quote
  (#5) Old
Freaky geeky
 
MissOwen's Avatar
MissOwen is great quiddich championMissOwen is great quiddich championMissOwen is great quiddich championMissOwen is great quiddich championMissOwen is great quiddich championMissOwen is great quiddich championMissOwen is great quiddich championMissOwen is great quiddich champion
Posts: 1,045
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Norfolk, UK
06-07-11, 10:08 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by lovelynails View Post
as listed its in same order which means the more of ingredients thats in it goes first to the least n both bottles read the same think i will try on myself as sugguested as surely they cant sell the same thing as 2 different products xx
try putting the base coat on you nails, curing for two minutes and wiping the sticky residue off..... if its as shiny and smooth as the top coat, then they may be the same, if not there is some significant difference!
Reply With Quote
  (#6) Old
CND Shellac Ambassador
 
Nailsinlondon1's Avatar
Nailsinlondon1 says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketNailsinlondon1 says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketNailsinlondon1 says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketNailsinlondon1 says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketNailsinlondon1 says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketNailsinlondon1 says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketNailsinlondon1 says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketNailsinlondon1 says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketNailsinlondon1 says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketNailsinlondon1 says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketNailsinlondon1 says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocket
Posts: 7,497
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Greven, Germany
06-07-11, 11:40 PM

They may be the same ingredients, but they may be in a different ratio.
The only one that can really answer that would be Georgie or Jason at Nail Harmony, maybe give them a call, they should have all the product details at hand xxxx
Reply With Quote
  (#7) Old
Grand Geek
 
Zingara's Avatar
Zingara says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketZingara says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketZingara says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketZingara says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketZingara says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketZingara says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketZingara says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketZingara says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketZingara says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketZingara says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketZingara says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocket
Posts: 3,095
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: North Wales
07-07-11, 09:13 AM

The MSDS shows them to be similar ingredients, in differing quantities and ratio's.

I'm sure your trainer or supplier wil supply you MSDS if you require.

Last edited by Zingara; 07-07-11 at 09:39 AM. Reason: spelling
Reply With Quote
  (#8) Old
Strictly Scottish Geek!
 
izzidoll's Avatar
izzidoll says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketizzidoll says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketizzidoll says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketizzidoll says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketizzidoll says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketizzidoll says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketizzidoll says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketizzidoll says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketizzidoll says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketizzidoll says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocketizzidoll says folks don't laugh so loud when you got a grand in your pocket
Posts: 12,101
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Scotland
07-07-11, 09:31 AM

Have you used this system?
I have, and the Gel Foundation basecoat is a totally different consistency and is applied differently from the Top it Off , and you use so little of it that cost wise it probably works out a lot cheaper than the Top it off topcoat!!

As for the ingredients being the same, think of it this way, most monomers and powders in acrylic systems have the same list of ingredients.....and yet prices and, more importantly, quality vary. This is because, as has already been pointed out, it is all down to the amount of each seperate ingredient that has been used.
Reply With Quote
  (#9) Old
Geeklin
lovelynailss head weighs 8lbs
Posts: 67
Join Date: May 2010
Location: essex
07-07-11, 10:13 AM

thanks guys i understand now xx
Reply With Quote
  (#10) Old
Moderate geek
 
Janiwanidoodaa's Avatar
Janiwanidoodaa has got laser envyJaniwanidoodaa has got laser envy
Posts: 87
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Essex
07-07-11, 11:51 AM

The ingredients are similar in Gelish Foundation and Gelish Top It Off but the ingredient ratios determine that they perform in very different ways.

Gelish Foundation creates a bond with the natural nail and the colour, Gelish Top It Off seals in the colour and protects it for weeks with an amazing shine.

You only need to use the products to see that they are very different in application, consistency and finish and if used in the wrong way you would get service breakdown.


Jan Soar
Head of Education
Nail Harmony UK
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On





© 1997-2014 Sweet Squared LLP