I've bought their gel eyeliner which was brilliant, and waterproof! So I bought a huge kit when I was in NY. the eyeshadows are crap, don't go on well and don't last, they almost rub off when trying to blend! Love the blushers that came with it and the lip glosses. I even got gel eyeliners in it, they are no way the same formula as the separate pots I bought as rub off easily.