Belmacil or Refectocil tint?

[AbbF1_]

changing my brand of tint, was wondering which tint is better

 

[PicklePie]

I have previously used Refectocil which is ok but fades quite quickly. I have recently tried Belmacil blue black for lashes and will be converting all my tints as it lasts ages, develops quickly and they have a great little shield that leaves minimal mess when applying.