Girl hit by police!

SalonGeek

Help Support SalonGeek:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Fingertips ND

Brand New Mummy Geek
Joined
Mar 8, 2005
Messages
4,336
Reaction score
106
Location
Huddersfield
Has anyone seen the news today about the 20 year old epileptic girl hit by a police man after damaging a parked car after being thrown out of a Sheffield nightclub?

What are your views?

Did she deserve it? Are the police hiding information?
 
if shes epileptic - is it not a tad irresponsible on her part to be getting that badly drunk?
 
nahh dont think she deserved it... sometimes those little hooligans could do with a sorting out might cut down on crime. ... i take it back only kidding
 
apparently the officer in question stated in his report that she wasn't intoxicated and he wasn't aware she was drunk.

she was however foaming at the mouth.

now i have been drunk a few times but never foamed at the mouth. I have epiliptic friends that do foam at the mouth during an attack.
 
what an arsehole....he should be banged up!! She was poss having a fit. Reasonable force...thats a term that gets miss used!
 
so in that case she cant use the fact that she was intoxicated to smash up someones car? why do it then? i wonder what the excuse is? sorry i need my car for work so i can earn and pay my mortgage - if some oik decided to smash it up just cos they got kicked out of a club id be pretty p***sed so no sympathy here for this -
sometimes people should just take the consequences for their own mindless actions
 
so in that case she cant use the fact that she was intoxicated to smash up someones car? why do it then? i wonder what the excuse is? sorry i need my car for work so i can earn and pay my mortgage - if some oik decided to smash it up just cos they got kicked out of a club id be pretty p***sed so no sympathy here for this -
sometimes people should just take the consequences for their own mindless actions

here here
 
no smoke without fire!
 
i'm not condoning what she did - just wanted your views.

i agree she was in the wrong for criminal damge but she was already being restrained by officers and she is only 8/9 stone - why was she then hit five times 'as hard as i possible could' (the words of the officer)
 
No one knows what was going on and I personally think it is wrong of the News showing this video until it has been fully investigated.
 
Well i expect once shes got her compensation she'll be ok.
 
I haven't seen this yet , but was she intending to damage the car or was it an involuntary action due to the onset of a seizure ?
 
The question I want to ask is why was she thrown out of the nightclub?
She must have been thrown out for a reason?
I've experienced quite a bit of epilepsy but I've yet to see someone damage a car in the process of having a seizure, unless she fell on it.
During a grand mal seizure people usually drop wherever they are and during a petit mal seizure I've never known anyone to foam at the mouth.
 
Sounds me to me like someone trying to get compo for being a drunken yob:rolleyes: Lord whatever happened to trying to be decent and hardworking, now we are having epilepsy used as an excuse for being a drunken scally oik. I wouldn't blame the copper if he had hit her, I'm only surprised more coppers don't with the derelicts they have to deal with these days. JMO
 
My close friends boyfriend is Epileptic - he tried to hide this from my friend for a while as he was ashamed of it. Anyways, one night after they had been out drinking alot to a club.... they were in his flat and he starting fitting in the bed... my friend really panicked and went over to him to help but he attacked her :eek: . She was frightened to death and they had a big fight and she ended up pulling a wardrobe over onto him to get out, legged it to a neighbours and called the police.

The police arrived, followed by an ambulance and an emergency nurse or something and after the police escorted her back into the property to get her clothes (this is the abridiged version!), he was sitting up fine and it all came out about his Epilepsy. He had been taking weight gain stuff or Steroids or something for fitness, and this with his Epilepsy gave him a really bad episode.

He has since had to give up a 30k job, hand in his driving licence and my friend now drives him around where necessary.

The point of this story is, he has no idea what he is doing when having a fit - who knows, if he can attack my friend, perhaps he could smash a car up?

I don't understand the illness at all.

A police officer, however, should never hit a person - restraint is different, but to whack someone is wrong.
 
Here's the news story from Sky News...
Sky News said:
A young woman repeatedly punched by a policeman is demanding an apology and compensation.
CCTV pictures show 20-year-old Toni Comer being hit five times by PC Anthony Mulhall.
The officer, who has been suspended from frontline duties, says he was trying to deaden her arm so she could be restrained with handcuffs.

The mother-of-one said: "I thought police arrested people for doing things like that, not that they did it themselves.
"Afterwards, there were bruises on the back of my neck, the side of my head and on my arms."
She added: "I would like to see some kind of justice so this never happens to anybody else in the future.
"He should pay some compensation for what he did to me."
She is taking civil action against the officer.

Ms Comer - who suffers from epilepsy - had been thrown out of the Niche nightclub in Sheffield. Police were called when she vandalised a car.
She admits drinking brandy and cokes before arriving at the club, but says her mind went blank after entering and she has no recollection of what followed.
PC Mulhall said he had been kicked and spat at by Ms Comer, who had also tried to bite him.
In a statement he said he tried to subdue her to no avail: "There was no visible effect and in the end I had to use brute force and both hands to bend her arm at the elbow to place her wrist in the cuff."
He said he hit her "as hard as I was physically able" to deaden her arm so she could be restrained.
She was put in cuffs and dragged away with her trousers down as a police dog handler watched.

Ms Comer has pleaded guilty to criminal damage and was given a conditional discharge and ordered to pay £250 compensation.
Ms Comer's parents, Leroy Walcott and Lisa Comer, said their daughter had a fit in the club.
Mr Walcott, told Sky News: "What kind of an example does this set? My daughter is 5ft 6ins and weighs nine stone and I'm sure two police officers could have restrained her. It's just not acceptable."

Ms Comer said her epilepsy started when she was 17 and pregnant with her three-year-old son Tyrees. She doesn't take medication because of possible side effects if she wants more children.
She added: "I'd like to see an apology and for the police to be aware that these type of illnesses are around, because it can be mistaken for being drunk."

The Independent Police Complaints Commission has launched an investigation into the allegations.
IPCC Commissioner Nicholas Long said: "I have seen the CCTV footage and decided it is in the public interest for a wholly independent investigation to be conducted."
South Yorkshire Police Chief Constable Meredydd Hughes told Sky News he'd been horrified when he first saw the CCTV clip. However, he added he had now seen the whole footage and there was more to the case than first met the eye.
She was drinking before going to the club and strangely doesn't remember anything else after that.
She was thrown out of the club and the police were called because she was vandalising a car.
She couldn't be handcuffed so the officer tried to deaden her arm to get the cuffs on her... I personally don't see a problem with that, she was causing criminal damage by vandalising the car and was obviously protesting after she'd spat at the officer and tried to bite him...

My take on it...
If it needed doing then what's the problem? If she'd been innocent then fair enough, but she wasn't.
 
I saw this at lunchtime today my thoughts its media hype yet again, The woman in question did not substain any injures or brusing and didnt need any medical attention following the arrest. Although I dont agree with any sort of violence I do feel that the police are doing a job that most of us wouldn't be prepared to do.
 
Don't blame this on epilepsy or any other illness, it really doesn't make any sense.
Would it be a problem if she was a diabetic? Would that make you kick cr*p out of a car or get thrown out of a nightclub?
We are going back to the olden days when people thought anyone with epilepsy was mad or a witch.
It's called an EXCUSE.
As you may have guessed...I don't buy it.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top