Have you ever been to a business that required you to remove your shoes before entering? I have not, whether that business is the doctor's office, grocery store, school, work, etc.
I do not have a home salon but if I did, I would treat my clients as my GUESTS and not require them to remove their footwear.
JMHO...
Actually, YES. At a dentist, and a hairdressing salon, and doc' offices (most especially in cold/wet months such as fall/winter/spring). It is the "usual" around here.
And YES I most definately expect my "guests" aka friends and family to remove their shoes and "respect" my home and the work I do to keep it clean.
it is the NORM around here to remove your shoes and when you don't, it's considered RUDE.
I suppose maybe it's a culture thing, dependant upon the country you live in?
So, here it is quite normal and no one has ever been offended by it.
If anything, on the rare occasions I say "go ahead, your shoes are dry" or "dont worry, I have to pass the broom anyway"; MOST will remove their footware anyway because they don't feel right keeping it on.
Regarding business expenses I "get " where you are coming from regarding deductions etc as well as insurance cover............. however a reasonable additional business expense I incur due to me choosing commercial rather than my residential property, is a substantial monthly rent. A home salon avoids this expense which is where I conclude that a carpet getting dirtier earlier because of business use is a reasonable business expense that must be borne if you choose to have a home salon.
While I may have less rent etc... I have other expenses that are 'increased' because I am located in a home. It all balances out and I don't think one way is more expensive than another when you do cost vs revenues. and remember, if I had my choice, I would be in a salon environment. I would probably make better revenues.
From a personal point of view, as a client I deem it unreasonable to be asked to remove my shoes as the Home Salon owner has chosen to use their home as their place of business, therefore as a client is is not my responsibility to "save" the salon owners carpet and if operating a business from their home means that a business owner needs to replace their carpet or clean it more often then its something that they as a business owner need to "live" with if they choose a Home Salon over commercial property.
Responsibilities aside... why is it unreasonable? Does it hurt to remove shoes and put on slippers? Not being argumentative. Still failing to understand the 'why' it would be unreasonable.
Kind of like - if you finish the toilet paper, please put another roll out. You're not responsible for it. But it is certainly considered considerate for the next person.
I'm talking about general consideration for others, be it business or home salon.
Anyhow, must be a culture thing because if you walked into my mother's house with your shoes on....... your ears would be blistered from a tongue-lashing. The same would happen just about any house you visited here. That is how we are brought up here. By the same token, my Nana was English and she insisted that the footware come off at the door. So maybe not? I don't know.
What I do know is that it's very common in businesses here. It's 'normal'. I've never been to a salon/business/doc's office locally that didn't offer slippers during cold/wet months. I personally would be embarassed to track dirt/water through someone's house/ business.
Another perspective: safety.
If someone comes in with wet footware and tracks puddles. Another comes along and WHOOPS down goes Gramma and breaks a hip.....
I don't want to be held responsible for Gramma ,and here I would be since it's my floor.