Grey area really............
There's nothing to say that, a person who hasn't got the natural gift, couldn't become a nail technician at all, but they maybe limited to what they can achieve.
Again just MHO
I do believe that you need some natural talent to be a nail tech, but that talent can take a long time to be developed. As far as the "eye" thing, I think you need an eye for detail, and that your "eye" for nails develops as you learn more about how a nail should be structured.
I actually agree with Tiger Jay....and to put it into one of your musical analogies!....some people may only be Pub musicians...whilst others go on to play the Stadiums!
I do think most people with reputable training can learn to put on a good looking set of nails...safely!!
However some people do just take to it, and are able to understand what you are telling them to do...and do it right away.
Others need a bit more...shall we say repetition, before brush techniques mix ratio etc are understood.
I shall say on a lot of my courses the slow starters have caught up with the ones who started off well...and I admit to being more proud of them as I know they put the blood sweat and tears in to it.
As for having an eye for nails.....I do think this comes with experience, it did for me, as I was a bit of a slow starter myself.
Yes their are people who let's face it will never put on a decent set of nails in a month of Sundays...I have found though that that is down to their attitude rather than their dexterity....and so far I have not had many on my Courses.
I know other Educators on site may not agree with me....but I can have an opinion!...I would be interested to see theirs.
I have not actually voted in the poll...as I agree with both statements.
I think it is something you can't really generalise on..every student is an individual and should only be judged on what work they produce.